Background: Chronic rhinosinusitis (CRS) is a common inflammatory condition affecting nose and paranasal mucosa. Anatomical variations of nose and paranasal sinuses have been implicated in the development of CRS. Objective: To investigate correlation between anatomical variations of nose and PNS with CRS. Methodology: A cross-sectional observational study was conducted on 80 participants diagnosed with CRS. Computed tomography scans were used to assess anatomical variations of nose and PNS. Results: Septal deviation was most common anatomical variation, present in 37.5% of participants. A significant association was found between anatomical variations of nose and PNS with CRS, with septal deviation and concha bullosa(31.3%) being most common variations associated with sinusitis. Conclusion: Study demonstrates a significant association between anatomical variations of nose and PNS with CRS, highlighting importance of considering these variations in diagnosis and treatment of CRS.
Chronic rhinosinusitis (CRS) is a condition characterized by inflammation of mucosa of nose and sinuses, resulting in symptoms like nasal congestion, facial pain, and loss of smell (1). Causative factors of CRS is complex and multifactorial, involving a combination of genetic, environmental, and anatomical factors (3,6).
Anatomical variations of the nose and paranasal sinuses specially osteomeatal complex (OMC) have been implicated in development of CRS. OMC is a critical area in nasal cavity where the frontal, anterior ethmoid, and maxillary sinuses drain (4). Anatomical variations of the OMC, such as septal deviation, concha bullosa, large agger nasi cell, and various attachment of uncinate process can obstruct the normal drainage of the sinuses, leading to inflammation and infection (2,7).
Aim:
This study aims to investigate the correlation between structural abnormalities of nose and paranasal sinuses leading to CRS in a sample of 80 participants. The study examined association between various anatomical variations of the OMC and different types of sinusitis, and explored the potential implications of these findings for the diagnosis and treatment of CRS.
Study Design:
This study was a cross-sectional observational study that aimed to investigate the correlation between anatomical variations of nose and paranasal sinuses with chronic rhinosinusitis (CRS).
Study Population:
Study consisted of 80 participants who were diagnosed with CRS. Participants were recruited from otorhinolaryngology department of a tertiary care hospital over a period of one year.
The inclusion criteria were:
The exclusion criteria were:
Data Collection:
Data Analysis:
Descriptive statistics: Frequency and percentage were used to describe the demographic data and the presence of anatomical variations of nose and PNS.
Study consisted of 80 participants, with 35 males (43.8%) and 45 females (56.3%). The age distribution showed that: 25% of participants were between 11-20 years old, 33.8% were between 21-30 years old, 27.5% were between 31-40 years old, 13.8% were between 41-50 years old. Overall, the study had a slightly higher representation of females and a relatively even distribution across the different age groups.
Table 1: Demographic characteristics of study participants
Age range(years) |
Gender |
Total (n/%) |
|
Male (n/%) |
Female (n/%) |
||
11-20 |
08(10%) |
12(15%) |
20(25%) |
21-30 |
12(15%) |
15(18.8%) |
27(33.8%) |
31-40 |
10(12.5%) |
12(15%) |
22(27.5%) |
41-50 |
05(6.3%) |
06(7.5%) |
11(13.8%) |
Total |
35(43.8%) |
45(56.3%) |
80(100%) |
Study revealed that maxillary sinusitis was the most common type, affecting 50% of participants. Bilateral sinusitis was more prevalent than unilateral sinusitis, with 63.8% of cases affecting both sides, followed by the right side (40%) and left side (35%). The distribution of sinusitis cases was as follows: maxillary (40 cases), frontal (26 cases), ethmoid (33 cases), and sphenoid (12 cases). Notably, some participants had multiple types of sinusitis, resulting in a total of 111 sinusitis cases among 80 participants.
Table 2: Distribution of study participants by sinusitis status
Sinusitis status |
Site of involvement |
Total (n/%) |
||
Right |
Left |
Bilateral |
||
Maxillary sinusitis |
12(15%) |
10(12.5%) |
18(22.5%) |
40(50%) |
Frontal sinusitis |
08(10%) |
06(7.5%) |
12(15%) |
26(32.5%) |
Ethmoidal sinusitis |
10(12.5%) |
08(10%) |
15(18.8%) |
33(41.3%) |
Sphenoidal sinusitis |
02(2.5%) |
04(5%) |
06(7.5%) |
12(15%) |
Study population exhibited various anatomical variations of nose and PNS. Most common variation was a septal deviation affecting 37.5% of population, followed by concha bullosa (31.3%), various attachments of uncinate process (27.5%), large agger nasi cell (25%), Haller cell (18.8%), and paradoxical middle turbinate (12.5%).
Table 3: Distribution of anatomical variations of nose and PNS
Anatomical variations |
Number(n) |
Percentage (%) |
Septal deviation |
30 |
37.5% |
Concha bullosa |
25 |
31.3% |
Agger nasi cell |
20 |
25% |
Haller cell |
15 |
18.8% |
Paradoxical Middle turbinate |
10 |
12.5% |
Various attachments of uncinate process |
22 |
27.5% |
This study shows the association between various anatomical variations and sinusitis in different sinuses. Septal deviation was most common variation, associated with 45% of maxillary, 46.2% of frontal, 45.5% of ethmoidal, and 41.7% of sphenoidal sinusitis. Other variations, such as concha bullosa, large agger nasi cell, haller cell, Paradoxical Middle turbinate, and Various attachments of uncinate process also showed significant associations with sinusitis in different sinuses. These findings suggest that anatomical variations play a significant role in the development of sinusitis in different sinuses.
Table 4: Association of different categories of sinusitis with anatomical variations of nose and PNS
Anatomical Variation |
Maxillary (%) |
Frontal (%) |
Ethmoidal (%) |
Sphenoidal (%) |
Septal deviation |
18 (45%) |
12 (46.2%) |
15 (45.5%) |
05 (41.7%) |
Concha bullosa |
15 (37.5%) |
10 (38.5%) |
12 (36.4%) |
04 (33.3%) |
Agger nasi cell |
12 (30%) |
08 (30.8%) |
10 (30.3%) |
03 (25%) |
Haller cell |
08 (20%) |
05 (19.2%) |
06 (18.2%) |
02 (16.7%) |
Paradoxical Middle turbinate |
05 (12.5%) |
03 (11.5%) |
04 (12.1%) |
01 (8.3%) |
Various attachments of uncinate process |
12 (30%) |
08 (30.8%) |
10 (30.3%) |
03 (25%) |
Table 5: Association of various attachment of uncinate process and different types of sinusitis
Various attachments of uncinate process |
Sinusitis |
|||
Maxillary |
Frontal |
Ethmoidal |
Sphenoidal |
|
Lamina papyracea |
06 |
04 |
05 |
01 |
Skull base |
03 |
02 |
03 |
01 |
Middle turbinate |
02 |
01 |
02 |
01 |
Lie free within middle meatus |
01 |
01 |
00 |
00 |
Total with variations |
12 |
08 |
10 |
03 |
This study aimed to investigate the correlation between chronic rhinosinusitis (CRS) and anatomical variations of nose and PNS. The results showed a significant association between various anatomical variations and CRS.
Demographic Characteristics
Demographic characteristics of study participants show a slightly higher representation of females (56.3%) compared to males (43.8%). This finding is consistent with previous studies that have reported a higher prevalence of chronic rhinosinusitis (CRS) in females8,9. Age distribution of the study participants shows a relatively even distribution across different age groups, with majority of participants (33.8%) between 21-30 years old. This finding is consistent with previous studies that have reported a peak prevalence of CRS in young adults10,11.
Comparison of demographic characteristics with other studies:
Studies |
Sample size |
Male |
Female |
Age range |
Current study |
80 |
43.8% |
56.3% |
11-50 |
Bhattacharyya et al.8 |
100 |
52% |
48% |
18-65 |
Kim et al.9 |
120 |
45.8% |
54.2% |
15-60 |
Sedaghat et al.10 |
90 |
48.9% |
51.1% |
18-55 |
Pearlman et al.11 |
150 |
46.7% |
53.3% |
18-70 |
Sinusitis Distribution
Study found that maxillary sinusitis was most common type, affecting 50% of participants, followed by ethmoidal sinusitis (41.3%), frontal sinusitis (32.5%), and sphenoidal sinusitis (15%).
Comparison of sinusitis distribution with other studies:
Studies |
Maxillary sinusitis |
Frontal sinusitis |
Ethmoidal sinusitis |
Sphenoidal sinusitis |
Current study |
50% |
32.5% |
41.3% |
15% |
Bhattacharyya et al.8 |
74.6% |
38.5% |
56.4% |
18.2% |
Kim et al.9 |
63.2% |
40.5% |
53.2% |
20.5% |
Sedaghat et al.10 |
55.6% |
29.6% |
44.4% |
11.1% |
Pearlman et al.11 |
60% |
35% |
50% |
15% |
Study also found that bilateral sinusitis was more prevalent than unilateral sinusitis, with 63.8% of cases affecting both sides. This finding is consistent with previous studies that have reported a high prevalence of bilateral sinusitis in patients with chronic rhinosinusitis 10,11. Findings are consistent with previous studies that have reported multiple sinuses involvement in patients with chronic rhinosinusitis12.
Studies |
Right side |
Left side |
Bilateral |
Current study |
40% |
35% |
63.8% |
Kim et al.9 |
26.6% |
26.6% |
73.4% |
Sedaghat et al.10 |
33.3% |
25.9% |
59.3% |
Pearlman et al.11 |
30% |
25% |
65% |
Anatomical Variations
Study found that septal deviation was most common anatomical variation of nose and PNS, affecting 37.5% of the population. This finding is consistent with previous studies that have reported septal deviation as a common anatomical variation13. Study also found that concha bullosa was second most common anatomical variation, affecting 31.3% of population. This finding is consistent with previous studies that have reported concha bullosa as a common anatomical variation14.
Comparison of anatomical variations of nose and PNS with other studies:
Anatomical variations |
Current study |
Stallman et al.13 |
Bolger et al.14 |
Kaygusuz et al.15 |
Septal deviation |
37.5% |
44% |
- |
- |
Concha bullosa |
31.3% |
- |
35% |
34.6% |
Agger nasi cell |
25% |
- |
10-15% |
20.5% |
Haller cell |
18.8% |
- |
10-15% |
15.4% |
Paradoxical Middle turbinate |
12.5% |
- |
10-15% |
11.5% |
Various attachments of uncinate process |
27.5% |
- |
10-40% |
- |
Anatomical variations and different sinusitis association
This study found that septal deviation was the most common anatomical variation associated with sinusitis in different sinuses. This finding is consistent with previous studies that have reported a significant association between septal deviation and sinusitis13. For example, a study by Kaygusuz et al.15 found that septal deviation was significantly associated with maxillary and frontal sinusitis.
Study also found that concha bullosa was associated with sinusitis in different sinuses. This finding is consistent with previous studies that have reported a significant association between concha bullosa and sinusitis14,17. For example, a study by Bolger et al.14 found that concha bullosa was a common anatomical variation in patients with chronic rhinosinusitis.
Study's findings on association between anatomical variations and sinusitis in different sinuses are consistent with previous studies that have reported a significant role of anatomical variations in the development of sinusitis15,16. For example, a study by Alkire et al.16 found that sinonasal anatomical variants were significantly associated with recurrent acute rhinosinusitis.
Various Uncinate process attachment
This study found that the most common attachment of the uncinate process was to the lamina papyracea, accounting for 6 cases in maxillary sinusitis, 4 cases in frontal sinusitis, and 5 cases in ethmoidal sinusitis. This finding is consistent with previous studies that have reported lamina papyracea as a common site of attachment for uncinate process14,17. Study also found that distribution of various attachments of the uncinate process differed among different types of sinusitis. For example, in sphenoidal sinusitis, all types of attachments were relatively evenly distributed, with 1 case each. This finding suggests that the anatomical characteristics of the uncinate process may vary among different sinusitis types.
Comparison of various attachments of uncinate process with other studies:
Various attachments of uncinate process |
Current study |
Bolger et al.14 |
Zinreich et al.17 |
Lamina papyracea |
Most common attachment |
Most common attachment |
Common attachment |
Skull base |
Less common attachment |
Less common attachment |
Less common attachment |
Middle turbinate |
Less common attachment |
Variable attachment |
Variable attachment |
Lie free within middle meatus |
Rare attachment |
Rare attachment |
Rare attachment |
In conclusion, present study demonstrated a significant association between anatomical variations of nose and PNS with CRS. Findings suggest that identifying and addressing these variations may be important for preventing and treating CRS. Study also highlights importance of considering anatomical variations of nose and PNS in diagnosis and treatment of CRS.