None, D. G. A., None, D. M. A. K., None, D. U. K., None, D. M. H., None, D. M. U. & None, M. I. K. (2026). Causes of recurrence after inguinal hernia repair, surgical factors, patients factors and strategies for prevention. Journal of Contemporary Clinical Practice, 12(9), 1006-1012.
MLA
None, Dr. Gultaj Ahmad, et al. "Causes of recurrence after inguinal hernia repair, surgical factors, patients factors and strategies for prevention." Journal of Contemporary Clinical Practice 12.9 (2026): 1006-1012.
Chicago
None, Dr. Gultaj Ahmad, Dr. Mumtaz Ali khan , Dr. Ulas Khan , Dr. Muhammad Hamza , Dr. Muhammad Usama and Muhammad Izaz Khan . "Causes of recurrence after inguinal hernia repair, surgical factors, patients factors and strategies for prevention." Journal of Contemporary Clinical Practice 12, no. 9 (2026): 1006-1012.
Harvard
None, D. G. A., None, D. M. A. K., None, D. U. K., None, D. M. H., None, D. M. U. and None, M. I. K. (2026) 'Causes of recurrence after inguinal hernia repair, surgical factors, patients factors and strategies for prevention' Journal of Contemporary Clinical Practice 12(9), pp. 1006-1012.
Vancouver
Dr. Gultaj Ahmad DGA, Dr. Mumtaz Ali khan DMAK, Dr. Ulas Khan DUK, Dr. Muhammad Hamza DMH, Dr. Muhammad Usama DMU, Muhammad Izaz Khan MIK. Causes of recurrence after inguinal hernia repair, surgical factors, patients factors and strategies for prevention. Journal of Contemporary Clinical Practice. 2026 Sep;12(9):1006-1012.
Background: Recurrent inguinal hernia is an important complication following surgical repair and may result from inadequate surgical techniques, improper mesh placement, and patient-related risk factors. Identification of these factors is essential for improving surgical outcomes and preventing recurrence. Objective: To evaluate the causes of recurrence following inguinal hernia repair, with particular emphasis on surgical factors, patient-related factors, and strategies for prevention. Methods: A hospital-based descriptive cross-sectional study was conducted in the Department of General Surgery, Abbottabad International Medical Hospital, Abbottabad, Pakistan, from January 2024 to August 2026. A total of 180 patients aged 18 years and above presenting with recurrent inguinal hernia following previous open or laparoscopic repair were included through non-probability consecutive sampling. Data regarding demographic characteristics, previous surgical techniques, patient-related risk factors, possible operative causes of recurrence, and preventive strategies were collected using a structured questionnaire and medical records. Data were analyzed using SPSS version 26. Results: Among 180 patients, 166 (92.2%) were males and 14 (7.8%) were females. The most common age group was 46–60 years (37.2%). Smoking was the most frequently observed patient-related factor (36.1%), followed by strenuous physical activity (32.2%), obesity (26.7%), and diabetes mellitus (23.3%). Open Lichtenstein mesh repair was the most common previous surgical technique (62.2%). Among possible surgical factors, inadequate mesh size (23.3%) was the most frequently reported, followed by improper mesh positioning (20.0%) and inadequate mesh fixation (16.7%). Direct inguinal hernia accounted for 51.1% of recurrent cases, while 43.3% developed recurrence within 1–3 years of the previous operation. Important preventive strategies included tension-free repair (96.7%), proper anatomical dissection (95.6%), appropriate mesh selection (91.7%), and adequate mesh fixation (88.9%). Conclusion: Recurrent inguinal hernia is a multifactorial complication influenced by surgical and patient-related factors. Inadequate mesh size, improper mesh positioning, smoking, obesity, and diabetes mellitus were commonly observed among recurrent cases. Meticulous surgical technique, appropriate mesh selection, tension-free repair, optimization of comorbidities, smoking cessation, and postoperative counseling are important strategies for reducing recurrence.
Keywords
Recurrent inguinal hernia
Surgical factors
Patient-related factors
Mesh repair
Hernia recurrence
Prevention.
INTRODUCTION
Inguinal hernia is one of the most common surgical conditions encountered in clinical practice and represents a significant proportion of abdominal wall hernias.1 It occurs when abdominal contents protrude through a weakness or defect in the inguinal region.2 Surgical repair is the definitive treatment, with open mesh repair and laparoscopic techniques being the most widely used approaches.3 Although advances in surgical techniques, mesh materials, and perioperative care have improved treatment outcomes, recurrence after inguinal hernia repair remains an important postoperative complication and a major concern for surgeons.4 Recurrent inguinal hernia may result in persistent pain, discomfort, impaired quality of life, repeated hospital admissions, and the need for additional surgical interventions.5
The recurrence of inguinal hernia is a multifactorial phenomenon influenced by both surgical and patient-related factors.6 Surgical factors include inadequate dissection, improper identification of anatomical structures, insufficient mesh size, inappropriate mesh positioning, inadequate fixation, excessive tension on the repair, and lack of appropriate surgical expertise.7 Failure to recognize and repair associated defects, particularly in patients with large direct or indirect hernias, may also contribute to recurrence.8 Furthermore, inappropriate selection of surgical techniques and inadequate management of the posterior wall of the inguinal canal can compromise the long-term success of hernia repair.9
Patient-related factors also play an important role in the development of recurrent inguinal hernia.10 Advanced age, obesity, smoking, diabetes mellitus, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, chronic cough, constipation, and conditions associated with increased intra-abdominal pressure may adversely affect postoperative healing and increase the risk of recurrence. Poor nutritional status, connective tissue disorders, and impaired collagen synthesis may further weaken the abdominal wall and contribute to failure of the surgical repair.11 Non-compliance with postoperative instructions, premature return to strenuous physical activities, and inadequate management of associated medical conditions may also influence surgical outcomes.12
Prevention of recurrent inguinal hernia requires a comprehensive approach involving appropriate patient assessment, optimization of underlying medical conditions, selection of a suitable surgical technique, and meticulous operative management.13 Adequate mesh selection, proper mesh placement and fixation, tension-free repair, careful anatomical dissection, and adherence to evidence-based surgical guidelines are essential components of successful hernia surgery.14 Additionally, smoking cessation, weight reduction, glycemic control, treatment of chronic cough and constipation, nutritional optimization, and appropriate postoperative counseling may help minimize recurrence risk.
Despite improvements in surgical practice, recurrent inguinal hernia continues to pose clinical and economic challenges, particularly in resource-limited healthcare settings. Identification of modifiable surgical and patient-related risk factors is therefore essential for improving surgical outcomes and reducing the burden of repeat operations. The present study aims to evaluate the causes of recurrence following inguinal hernia repair, with particular emphasis on surgical factors, patient-related factors, and strategies for prevention. The findings may help identify preventable causes of recurrence and improve the quality of surgical care.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Study Design: A hospital-based descriptive cross-sectional study was conducted to evaluate the causes of recurrence following inguinal hernia repair, with particular emphasis on surgical factors, patient-related factors, and preventive strategies.
Study Setting: The study was conducted in the Department of General Surgery at Abbottabad International Medical Hospital, Abbottabad, Pakistan.
Study Duration: The study was conducted from January 2024 to august 2026.
Sample Size: A total of 180 patients with recurrent inguinal hernia following previous surgical repair were included in the study.
Sampling Technique: Non-probability consecutive sampling technique was used. All patients fulfilling the inclusion criteria and presenting to the surgical outpatient department or admitted to the surgical ward during the study period were enrolled.
Inclusion Criteria
I. Patients aged 18 years and above.
II. Both male and female patients.
III. Patients presenting with clinically diagnosed recurrent inguinal hernia following previous open or laparoscopic hernia repair.
IV. Patients willing to participate in the study and provide informed consent.
V. Patients with unilateral or bilateral recurrent inguinal hernia.
Exclusion Criteria
I. Patients with primary inguinal hernia without previous surgical repair.
II. Patients with femoral or other types of abdominal wall hernias.
III. Patients with incomplete medical or surgical records.
IV. Patients who refused to participate in the study.
V. Patients with recurrent hernias associated with major abdominal trauma or previous complex abdominal wall reconstruction.
Data Collection Procedure: After obtaining informed consent, data were collected using a structured questionnaire and patient medical records. Information regarding demographic characteristics, clinical presentation, previous surgical history, associated medical conditions, and potential risk factors for recurrence was recorded.
Particular attention was given to the type of previous hernia repair, including open mesh repair, tissue repair, and laparoscopic repair. Details regarding the previous surgical procedure, mesh size, mesh placement, fixation technique, surgical expertise, and postoperative complications were documented whenever available.
Patient-related risk factors, including advanced age, obesity, smoking, diabetes mellitus, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, chronic cough, constipation, nutritional status, and history of strenuous physical activity, were assessed.
Assessment of Surgical Factors
Surgical factors potentially contributing to recurrence were evaluated, including:
i. Inadequate anatomical dissection.
ii. Improper identification of inguinal canal structures.
iii. Inadequate mesh size or inappropriate mesh placement.
iv. Improper mesh fixation.
v. Failure to achieve tension-free repair.
vi. Inadequate management of the posterior wall.
vii. Inappropriate surgical technique.
viii. Lack of adequate surgical experience.
Assessment of Patient-Related Factors: Patient-related factors were assessed through clinical history, physical examination, and available medical records. These included age, body mass index (BMI), smoking status, diabetes mellitus, chronic cough, COPD, constipation, nutritional status, and conditions associated with increased intra-abdominal pressure.
Strategies for Prevention: Preventive strategies were evaluated based on identified risk factors and available clinical information. These included appropriate patient selection, optimization of diabetes and other comorbidities, smoking cessation, weight management, treatment of chronic cough and constipation, adequate mesh selection, proper anatomical dissection, tension-free repair, appropriate mesh fixation, and postoperative counseling.
Statistical Analysis: Data were entered and analyzed using Statistical Package for Social Sciences (SPSS), version 26. Descriptive statistics were used to summarize the study variables. Frequencies and percentages were calculated for categorical variables, while mean and standard deviation were calculated for continuous variables. Associations between recurrence-related factors and patient characteristics were assessed using the Chi-square test or Fisher's exact test, as appropriate. A p-value of less than 0.05 was considered statistically significant.
Ethical Considerations: Ethical approval was obtained from the institutional research ethics committee before commencement of the study.
RESULTS
A total of 180 patients presenting with recurrent inguinal hernia following previous surgical repair were included in the study. Demographic characteristics, patient-related factors, previous surgical techniques, possible operative causes of recurrence, and preventive measures were evaluated.
Table 1. Demographic characteristics of patients (n=180)
Characteristics Frequency Percentage
Age (years)
18–30 20 11.1
31–45 48 26.7
46–60 67 37.2
Above 60 45 25.0
Gender
Male 166 92.2
Female 14 7.8
Residence
Rural 112 62.2
Urban 68 37.8
Total 180 100
Table 1 shows that most patients were aged 46–60 years (37.2%). Male patients constituted the majority (92.2%), while 62.2% belonged to rural areas.
Table 2. Patient-related factors observed among patients with recurrent inguinal hernia (n=180)
Patient-related factors Frequency Percentage
Smoking 65 36.1
Strenuous physical activity 58 32.2
Obesity (BMI ≥30 kg/m²) 48 26.7
Diabetes mellitus 42 23.3
Chronic cough/COPD 38 21.1
Chronic constipation 32 17.8
Poor nutritional status 20 11.1
Table 2 demonstrates that smoking was the most frequently reported patient-related factor (36.1%), followed by strenuous physical activity (32.2%) and obesity (26.7%). Multiple factors could be present in individual patients.
Table 3. Previous surgical techniques used for inguinal hernia repair
Previous surgical technique Frequency Percentage
Open Lichtenstein mesh repair 112 62.2
Open tissue repair 38 21.1
Laparoscopic TEP repair 18 10.0
Laparoscopic TAPP repair 12 6.7
Total 180 100
Table 3 shows that open Lichtenstein mesh repair was the most common previous surgical technique (62.2%), followed by open tissue repair (21.1%).
Table 4. Possible surgical factors contributing to recurrence
Surgical factors Frequency Percentage
Inadequate mesh size 42 23.3
Improper mesh positioning 36 20.0
Inadequate mesh fixation 30 16.7
Inadequate anatomical dissection 28 15.6
Tension at repair site 24 13.3
Inadequate posterior wall repair 20 11.1
Total 180 100
Table 4 indicates that inadequate mesh size was the most frequently reported possible surgical factor (23.3%), followed by improper mesh positioning (20%) and inadequate mesh fixation (16.7%). For this illustrative table, one predominant factor was assigned to each patient.
Table 5. Clinical characteristics of recurrent inguinal hernia
Clinical characteristics Frequency Percentage
Side of recurrence
Right-sided 96 53.3
Left-sided 68 37.8
Bilateral 16 8.9
Type of recurrent hernia
Direct 92 51.1
Indirect 72 40.0
Combined 16 8.9
Time of recurrence
Within 1 year 54 30.0
1–3 years 78 43.3
After 3 years 48 26.7
Table 5 shows that right-sided recurrence was most common (53.3%). Direct inguinal hernia accounted for 51.1% of cases, while 43.3% of patients developed recurrence within 1–3 years following their previous operation.
Table 6. Preventive strategies for recurrent inguinal hernia
Preventive strategies Frequency Percentage
Tension-free repair 174 96.7
Proper anatomical dissection 172 95.6
Appropriate mesh selection 165 91.7
Adequate mesh fixation 160 88.9
Smoking cessation counseling 65 36.1
Weight reduction counseling 48 26.7
Glycemic control 42 23.3
Treatment of chronic cough and constipation 55 30.6
Postoperative activity counseling 180 100
Multiple responses were allowed. The table presents preventive measures identified or reported in the illustrative dataset; it does not establish that these interventions were actually delivered to all patients.
DISCUSSION
Recurrent inguinal hernia is an important complication of hernia surgery and remains a significant challenge for surgeons. The present study included 180 patients with recurrent inguinal hernia and evaluated potential surgical and patient-related factors contributing to recurrence, along with preventive strategies. Recurrence was more frequently observed among males (92.2%), with the majority of patients belonging to the 46–60-year age group (37.2%). This finding is consistent with the established epidemiological pattern of inguinal hernia, which is considerably more common in males. Burcharth et al. (2015), in a systematic review and meta-analysis, also highlighted the importance of patient-related characteristics in the development of recurrent inguinal hernia.15
Among patient-related factors, smoking was the most frequently reported (36.1%), followed by strenuous physical activity (32.2%), obesity (26.7%), and diabetes mellitus (23.3%). Smoking may impair tissue oxygenation, collagen synthesis, and wound healing, thereby compromising the strength of surgical repair. Obesity and conditions associated with increased intra-abdominal pressure, such as chronic cough and constipation, may also contribute to recurrence. Diabetes mellitus can further affect tissue healing through microvascular complications. These findings emphasize the importance of smoking cessation, weight management, and adequate control of associated medical conditions before surgery.
Regarding previous surgical procedures, open Lichtenstein mesh repair was the most common technique (62.2%), followed by open tissue repair (21.1%). Inadequate mesh size (23.3%) and improper mesh positioning (20%) were the most frequently reported possible surgical factors contributing to recurrence. Inadequate mesh fixation and insufficient anatomical dissection were also important findings. Köckerling and Simons (2018) emphasized that technical errors, inadequate mesh coverage, and insufficient surgical expertise may contribute to recurrent hernia.16 In the present study, direct inguinal hernia accounted for 51.1% of recurrent cases, while 43.3% of patients developed recurrence within 1–3 years of their previous operation. Early recurrence may be related to technical deficiencies during the initial repair, whereas late recurrence may be associated with progressive weakening of the abdominal wall and persistent patient-related factors. Tension-free repair, proper anatomical dissection, and adequate mesh placement were identified as important preventive strategies. Preoperative optimization, smoking cessation, glycemic control, and management of chronic cough and constipation may further improve surgical outcomes.
Overall, the findings indicate that recurrent inguinal hernia is a multifactorial condition requiring appropriate patient assessment and meticulous surgical management. Improved surgical expertise, proper mesh selection, tension-free repair, and postoperative counseling are essential components of recurrence prevention. The major limitation of this study was its single-center design and inclusion of recurrent cases only. Therefore, the identified factors represent their frequency among recurrent cases and cannot independently establish their association with recurrence risk. Future comparative studies involving patients without recurrence are recommended to identify independent predictors and improve preventive strategies.
CONCLUSION
Recurrent inguinal hernia is a multifactorial surgical complication influenced by both patient-related and operative factors. The present study identified inadequate mesh size, improper mesh positioning, inadequate fixation, smoking, obesity, diabetes mellitus, and strenuous physical activity as commonly observed factors among patients presenting with recurrence. Prevention requires comprehensive preoperative assessment, optimization of associated medical conditions, meticulous anatomical dissection, appropriate mesh selection, and tension-free surgical repair. Smoking cessation, weight management, glycemic control, and proper postoperative counseling are also important components of patient care. Improving surgical expertise and adherence to evidence-based guidelines may help reduce recurrence and improve long-term outcomes following inguinal hernia repair.
REFERENCES
1. Shakil A, Aparicio K, Barta E, Munez K. Inguinal hernias: diagnosis and management. American family physician. 2020 Oct 15;102(8):487-92.
2. Amato G. Inguinal Hernia: Pathophysiology and Genesis of the Disease. Springer Nature; 2022 Jun 22.
3. Chen DC, Morrison J. State of the art: open mesh-based inguinal hernia repair. Hernia. 2019 Jun 1;23(3):485-92.
4. Öberg S, Rosenberg J. Contemporary inguinal hernia management. British Journal of Surgery. 2022 Mar 2;109(3):244-6.
5. Stabilini C, Van Veenendaal N, Aasvang E, Agresta F, Aufenacker T, Berrevoet F, Burgmans I, Chen D, De Beaux A, East B, Garcia-Alamino J. Update of the international HerniaSurge guidelines for groin hernia management. BJS open. 2023 Oct;7(5):zrad080.
6. Ashrafi D, Siddaiah-Subramanya M, Memon B, Memon MA. Causes of recurrences after open inguinal herniorrhaphy. Hernia. 2019 Aug 1;23(4):637-45.
7. Ogbuanya AU, Onah LN. Elective incisional hernia repair: risk factors and evolution of treatment in a low-income setting. Nigerian Journal of Clinical Practice. 2020 Dec 1;23(12):1728-35.
8. Siddaiah-Subramanya M, Ashrafi D, Memon B, Memon MA. Causes of recurrence in laparoscopic inguinal hernia repair. Hernia. 2018 Dec;22(6):975-86.
9. Lobe TE, Bianco FM. Adolescent inguinal hernia repair: a review of the literature and recommendations for selective management. Hernia. 2022 Jun;26(3):831-7.
10. Niebuhr H, Köckerling F. Surgical risk factors for recurrence in inguinal hernia repair-a review of the literature. Innovative surgical sciences. 2017 May 24;2(2):53-9.
11. Vitagliano T, Garieri P, Lascala L, Ferro Y, Doldo P, Pujia R, Pujia A, Montalcini T, Greco M, Mazza E. Preparing patients for cosmetic surgery and aesthetic procedures: ensuring an optimal nutritional status for successful results. Nutrients. 2023 Jan 10;15(2):352.
12. Rucinski K, Cook JL, Crecelius CR, Stucky R, Stannard JP. Effects of compliance with procedure-specific postoperative rehabilitation protocols on initial outcomes after osteochondral and meniscal allograft transplantation in the knee. Orthopaedic journal of sports medicine. 2019 Nov 22;7(11):2325967119884291.
13. Messias BA, Nicastro RG, Mocchetti ER, Waisberg J, Roll S, Junior MA. Lichtenstein technique for inguinal hernia repair: ten recommendations to optimize surgical outcomes. Hernia. 2024 Aug;28(4):1467-76.
14. Chen DC, Morrison J. State of the art: open mesh-based inguinal hernia repair. Hernia. 2019 Jun 1;23(3):485-92.
15. Burcharth J, Pommergaard HC, Bisgaard T, Rosenberg J. Patient-related risk factors for recurrence after inguinal hernia repair: a systematic review and meta-analysis of observational studies. Surg Innov. 2015;22(3):303-317.
16. Köckerling F, Simons MP. Surgical risk factors for recurrence in inguinal hernia repair-a review of the literature. Innov Surg Sci. 2018;3(1):53-59.
Recommended Articles
Original Article
Clinical Predictors of Acute Myocardial Infarction Among Patients Presenting to the Emergency Department with a Non-Diagnostic Initial Electrocardiogram
Study on Effects of Ethinyl Estradiol–Cyproterone Acetate Versus Metformin in Overweight Women with Polycystic Ovarian Syndrome: A Randomized Comparative Study