Contents
pdf Download PDF
pdf Download XML
81 Views
12 Downloads
Share this article
Research Article | Volume 12 Issue 11 (November, 2026) | Pages 417 - 421
A Prospective Comparative Study of Primary Repair with Graham’s Omental Patch Versus Primary Repair with Gastrojejunostomy in Perforative Peptic Peritonitis
 ,
 ,
1
Assistant professor Department of General Surgery PRM Medical College and Hospital, Baripada, Odisha,
2
Assistant professor, Department of Community Medicine SLS Medical college and Hospital Phulbani, Odisha,
Under a Creative Commons license
Open Access
Received
Oct. 5, 2026
Revised
Oct. 21, 2026
Accepted
Nov. 4, 2026
Published
Nov. 19, 2026
Abstract
Background: Perforative peptic peritonitis remains a critical surgical emergency in rural and tribal belts. While Graham's omental patch is the standard, surgeons often encounter large or chronic callous perforations where simple closure risks suture-line tension and future gastric outlet obstruction (GOO). This study compares outcomes between primary repair alone and primary repair combined with a drainage procedure (gastrojejunostomy). Methods: A prospective interventional study of 96 hemodynamically stable patients was conducted at PRM MCH, Baripada (June 2025–May 2026). Patients were assigned based on intraoperative findings and surgical judgment into Group A (Primary Repair, n=48) and Group B (Primary Repair + Gastrojejunostomy, n=48). Parameters including operative time, complications, hospital stay, and 6-month recurrence were analyzed. A p-value <0.05 was considered statistically significant. Results: Both groups shared similar demographics, with a high incidence of delayed presentation (>24 hours). Group A had a significantly shorter operative time (66.5 vs. 110.2 mins, p<0.01) and faster return of bowel function. However, Group B demonstrated a significant reduction in 6-month gastric outlet obstruction (0% vs. 8.3%, p=0.04) and recurrent ulceration (2.1% vs. 16.7%, p=0.02). 30-day mortality was comparable (6.2% vs 8.3%, p=0.71). Conclusion: Simple omental patch repair remains the ideal damage-control approach for small, acute perforations. However, for large (>10 mm), fibrotic, or callous perforations, the addition of a posterior gastrojejunostomy is a safe and highly effective strategy that provides definitive long-term protection against stenosis and recurrence without increasing mortality.
Keywords
INTRODUCTION
Peptic ulcer perforation is one of the most frequently encountered acute abdominal emergencies, particularly in the agricultural and tribal populations of northern Odisha. At Pandit Raghunath Murmu Medical College and Hospital (PRM MCH) in Baripada, surgeons routinely manage patients arriving with generalized peritonitis, often delayed by days due to distance, reliance on indigenous medicine, and heavy unsupervised use of non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) for labor-induced body aches. The operative mandate is clear: rapid source control and thorough peritoneal lavage. Historically, Roscoe Graham's live omental patch repair has been the gold standard due to its speed and simplicity. It limits anesthesia exposure, which is critical for patients presenting in varying degrees of septic shock. However, the morphology of these perforations varies greatly on the operating table. Surgeons frequently encounter giant duodenal perforations (>10 mm) or those surrounded by dense, fibrotic, callous margins. Attempting simple primary closure in these scenarios often pulls friable tissues together under extreme tension, risking immediate postoperative blowout or precipitating late cicatricial gastric outlet obstruction (GOO). In these complex cases, supplementing the primary repair with a drainage procedure—specifically a posterior retrocolic gastrojejunostomy—can theoretically bypass the diseased pyloroduodenal segment and divert gastric acid. Despite its anatomical advantages, performing a second anastomosis in a contaminated field prolongs operative time and raises concerns regarding added morbidity. This prospective study was undertaken to systematically evaluate whether the long-term benefits of gastrojejunostomy outweigh the immediate surgical risks in a resource-limited tertiary care setting.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
This was a prospective, comparative interventional study carried out at the Department of General Surgery, PRM MCH, Baripada, over a 12-month period from June 2025 to May 2026. The study enrolled 96 consecutive adult patients presenting with clinical and radiological signs of perforative peritonitis (pneumoperitoneum) who were subsequently confirmed intraoperatively to have a pre-pyloric or first-part duodenal perforation. Following aggressive initial resuscitation with intravenous crystalloids, antibiotics, and nasogastric decompression, patients were divided into two equal groups of 48 based on surgical allocation matching: • Group A: Underwent simple primary closure reinforced with a Graham’s omental patch. • Group B: Underwent primary closure with a Graham’s patch followed by a retrocolic, isoperistaltic posterior gastrojejunostomy. The decision to perform gastrojejunostomy was guided by intraoperative findings such as large ulcer size (>10 mm), callous/friable margins, and hemodynamic stability permitting prolonged anesthesia. Postoperatively, patients were monitored for return of bowel function, initiation of oral feeds, surgical site infections (SSI), respiratory complications, and biliary leaks. Following discharge on standard H. pylori eradication therapy, patients were followed up clinically and endoscopically at 6 months. Continuous data were analyzed using the student’s t-test, and categorical data via the Chi-square test, with p < 0.05 considered statistically significant.
RESULTS
The study successfully evaluated 96 patients. The analytical findings across demographics, intraoperative metrics, recovery milestones, complications, and follow-up are detailed in the tables and descriptions below. Description of Table 1: This table outlines the baseline demographic parameters of the 96 participants. Both groups were well-matched in terms of mean age (mid-40s) and a strong male predominance, reflecting the local agricultural workforce. Notably, approximately 70% of patients in both arms presented to the emergency room more than 24 hours after the onset of symptoms, highlighting the logistical delays typical of the region. There was no statistically significant baseline difference between the groups, ensuring a valid comparative foundation. Table 1: Baseline Demographic Profile and Presentation Parameters Parameter Group A (n=48) Group B (n=48) p-value Significance Mean Age (Years ± SD) 44.8 ± 12.1 46.3 ± 13.0 0.55 Not Significant Male : Female Ratio 4.3 : 1 3.8 : 1 0.78 Not Significant Presentation > 24 hours, n (%) 33 (68.7%) 35 (72.9%) 0.65 Not Significant History of chronic NSAID use, n (%) 28 (58.3%) 30 (62.5%) 0.67 Not Significant Free gas under diaphragm, n (%) 43 (89.5%) 45 (93.7%) 0.47 Not Significant Description of Table 2: Table 2 highlights the intraoperative findings and surgical duration. Because Group B was selected partly based on the severity of the ulcer morphology, a significantly higher proportion of patients in Group B had perforations exceeding 10 mm in size (39.5%) and margins described as callous or friable (52.0%). Predictably, the addition of the posterior gastrojejunostomy anastomosis dramatically increased the mean operative time from 66.5 minutes in Group A to 110.2 minutes in Group B (p < 0.01). Table 2: Intraoperative Findings and Operative Duration Parameter Group A (n=48) Group B (n=48) p-value Significance Operative Time (minutes ± SD) 66.5 ± 13.2 110.2 ± 19.5 < 0.01 Highly Significant Perforation Size > 10 mm, n (%) 7 (14.5%) 19 (39.5%) 0.01 Significant Callous or Friable Ulcer Margins, n (%) 9 (18.7%) 25 (52.0%) < 0.01 Highly Significant Peritoneal fluid volume > 500 mL, n (%) 30 (62.5%) 32 (66.6%) 0.67 Not Significant Description of Table 3: Early postoperative recovery milestones are captured in Table 3. Group A, which underwent a less invasive and shorter procedure, showed a faster physiological recovery. The return of audible bowel sounds and the initiation of oral sips occurred roughly one full day earlier in Group A compared to Group B, leading to a statistically significant shorter overall hospital stay (8.3 vs. 10.9 days, p < 0.01). Table 3: Early Postoperative Recovery Milestones Recovery Parameter Group A (n=48) Group B (n=48) p-value Significance Return of Bowel Sounds (days ± SD) 2.7 ± 0.8 3.7 ± 1.1 < 0.01 Significant Initiation of Oral Sips (days ± SD) 4.0 ± 1.0 5.1 ± 1.2 < 0.01 Significant Abdominal Drain Removal (days ± SD) 4.8 ± 1.3 5.6 ± 1.5 0.03 Significant Mean Total Hospital Stay (days ± SD) 8.3 ± 2.2 10.9 ± 2.8 < 0.01 Highly Significant Description of Table 4: Table 4 compares the 30-day early morbidity and mortality rates between the two cohorts. Superficial surgical site infections (SSI) and basal pulmonary complications were slightly higher in Group B, likely a consequence of prolonged anesthesia and a secondary anastomosis, but these differences did not achieve statistical significance. The incidence of postoperative biliary leaks from the primary suture line was lower in Group B (2.1% vs 8.3%), as the gastrojejunostomy effectively decompressed the duodenum. Importantly, the extended surgery in Group B did not significantly increase the 30-day mortality rate (6.2% vs 8.3%, p=0.71). Table 4: 30-Day Postoperative Complications and Mortality Complication Group A (n=48) Group B (n=48) p-value Significance Surgical Site Infection (SSI), n (%) 7 (14.5%) 10 (20.8%) 0.42 Not Significant Pulmonary Complications, n (%) 5 (10.4%) 8 (16.7%) 0.37 Not Significant Postoperative Biliary / Suture Leak, n (%) 4 (8.3%) 1 (2.1%) 0.16 Not Significant 30-Day In-Hospital Mortality, n (%) 3 (6.2%) 4 (8.3%) 0.71 Not Significant Description of Table 5: The most defining clinical results emerged during the 6-month clinical and endoscopic follow-up (excluding the 7 mortalities), as shown in Table 5. Group A suffered a significantly higher rate of symptomatic gastric outlet obstruction (8.8%) due to cicatricial narrowing of the repaired duodenum, whereas absolutely no patient in Group B developed this complication (0%, p=0.04). Furthermore, symptomatic ulcer recurrence was notably higher in Group A (17.7% vs. 2.2%, p=0.02). Conversely, mild-to-moderate endoscopic bile reflux gastritis was statistically higher in Group B (13.6% vs. 2.2%, p=0.04), confirming the expected anatomical trade-offs of the bypass procedure. Table 5: 6-Month Follow-Up Outcomes (Among 89 Survivors) Follow-Up Outcome Group A (n=45) Group B (n=44) p-value Significance Gastric Outlet Obstruction, n (%) 4 (8.8%) 0 (0.0%) 0.04 Significant Endoscopic Ulcer Recurrence, n (%) 8 (17.7%) 1 (2.2%) 0.02 Significant Endoscopic Bile Reflux Gastritis, n (%) 1 (2.2%) 6 (13.6%) 0.04 Significant Dyspepsia requiring prolonged PPI, n (%) 9 (20.0%) 5 (11.3%) 0.26 Not Significant
DISCUSSION
Surgical decision-making in peritonitis involves a delicate balancing act: achieving rapid damage control against preserving the long-term patency of the gastrointestinal tract. In our cohort at PRM MCH Baripada, delayed presentation (>24 hours in roughly 70% of cases) and heavy reliance on over-the-counter analgesics defined the demographic baseline, echoing epidemiological patterns across rural India. When faced with a soft, small (<5 mm) perforation, simple closure with a live omental patch is irrefutably the operation of choice. As demonstrated in Table 3, Group A benefited from a rapid operative course (mean 66.5 minutes) and a significantly shorter hospital stay. This minimalist approach limits physiological stress in compromised patients. However, our study illuminates the pitfalls of relying universally on simple closure. In patients with large, friable, or fibrotic perforations—disproportionately allocated to Group B via surgical judgment—simple closure risks kinking the duodenum. Table 5 demonstrates that primary repair alone (Group A) carried an 8.8% risk of subsequent gastric outlet obstruction and a 17.7% risk of recurrent ulceration over 6 months. In stark contrast, adding a retrocolic gastrojejunostomy entirely eliminated GOO (0%) and slashed ulcer recurrence to 2.2%. The physiological diversion of acidic chyme and the mechanical decompression of the scarred pylorus provide profound long-term healing advantages. Critics of gastrojejunostomy rightfully point to the prolonged operative time—an additional 40+ minutes in a contaminated field. Yet, as Table 4 validates, this extended duration did not translate to a statistically significant rise in 30-day mortality (6.2% vs 8.3%, p=0.71). The primary postoperative penalty was a higher rate of easily managed bile reflux gastritis in Group B (13.6%). Given the immense socioeconomic burden placed on rural laborers who require recurrent hospital admissions or repeated endoscopic dilations for GOO, performing a definitive drainage procedure upfront offers substantial value.
CONCLUSION
Primary repair reinforced with Graham’s omental patch remains the cornerstone for treating the majority of acute peptic perforations, yielding fast recovery and minimal operative trauma. Nevertheless, surgical strategy must adapt to local tissue pathology. In the presence of giant perforations (>10 mm), dense chronicity, or callous pyloric margins, supplementing the primary repair with a posterior gastrojejunostomy proves highly advantageous. This combination securely decompresses the compromised duodenum, successfully negating the long-term risks of gastric outlet obstruction and ulcer recurrence without imposing a statistically significant increase in perioperative mortality.
REFERENCES
1. Soreide K, Thorsen K, Harrison EM, et al. Perforated peptic ulcer. Lancet. 2015;386(10000):1288-1298. 2. Tarasconi A, Coccolini F, Biffl WL, et al. Perforated and bleeding peptic ulcer: WSES guidelines. World J Emerg Surg. 2020;15:3. 3. Jhobta RS, Attri AK, Kaushik R, et al. Spectrum of perforation peritonitis in India-review of 504 consecutive cases. World J Emerg Surg. 2006;1:26. 4. Chakma SM, Singh RL, Parmekar MV, et al. Spectrum of perforation peritonitis. J Clin Diagn Res. 2013;7(11):2518-2520. 5. Bali RS, Verma S, Agarwal PN, et al. Perforation peritonitis and the developing world. ISRN Surg. 2014;2014:105492. 6. Boey J, Choi SK, Poon A, et al. Risk stratification in perforated duodenal ulcers. Ann Surg. 1987;205(1):22-26. 7. Cellan-Jones CJ. A rapid method of treatment in perforated duodenal ulcer. Br Med J. 1929;1(3571):1076-1077. 8. Graham RR. The treatment of perforated duodenal ulcers. Surg Gynecol Obstet. 1937;64:235-238. 9. Gupta S, Kaushik R, Sharma R, et al. The management of large perforations of duodenal ulcers. BMC Surg. 2005;5:15. 10. Lal P, Vindal A, Hadke NS. Controlled tube duodenostomy in the management of giant duodenal ulcer perforation. Am J Surg. 2009;198(3):319-323. 11. Jani K, Saxena AK, Vaghasia R. Omental plugging for large-sized duodenal peptic perforations. South Med J. 2006;99(5):467-471. 12. Rajput D, Gupta A, Kumar S, Nanda G. Comparative study between simple closure with omental patch and closure with gastrojejunostomy in large duodenal ulcer perforation. Int Surg J. 2018;5(4):1342-1347. 13. Ng EK, Lam YH, Sung JJ, et al. Eradication of Helicobacter pylori prevents recurrence of ulcer after simple closure of duodenal ulcer perforation. Ann Surg. 2000;231(2):153-158. 14. Buck DL, Vester-Andersen M, Moller MH. Surgical delay is a critical determinant of survival in perforated peptic ulcer. Br J Surg. 2013;100(8):1045-1049. 15. Chaudhary V, Bano S, Kumar P, Singh SP. A prospective study comparing Graham's omental patch repair with primary closure plus gastrojejunostomy in chronic and giant peptic perforations. J Evolution Med Dent Sci. 2021;10(18):1310-1315.
Recommended Articles
Research Article
Perinatal Outcome In Neonates Born To High Risk Pregnancies –A Cross Sectional Observational Study
...
Published: 19/11/2026
Research Article
Adenoidectomy and Endoscopic Myringotomy with and without ventilation tube insertion for Treatment of Otitis Media with Effusion in 6-12 years old Children.
...
Published: 30/09/2026
Research Article
Clinico-Aetiological Profile And Short-Term Outcomes Of Children Aged 1 Month To 18 Years Presenting With Seizure At A Tertiary Care Centre
Published: 19/11/2026
Original Article
Association of Perceived Academic Stress with Cardiac Autonomic Function Among Undergraduate Medical Students: A Heart Rate Variability Study
Published: 27/12/2025
Chat on WhatsApp
© Copyright Journal of Contemporary Clinical Practice